Freight Brokers
Montgomery v. Caribe Transport: What the Supreme Court Ruling Means for Freight Brokers
The CargoLabs Team6 min read
On May 14, 2026, a unanimous Supreme Court held that a freight broker can be sued under state law for negligently hiring an unsafe motor carrier. The case is Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, and it settles a question that had split the federal courts for years. If you arrange freight for a living, the carrier you pick is now your legal exposure in all 50 states.
What happened in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II
In December 2017, Shawn Montgomery had pulled over on Interstate 70 in Illinois when a tractor-trailer hit his stopped vehicle. He lost a leg and suffered other permanent injuries. The truck was hauling a load of plastic pots for Caribe Transport II, a motor carrier. C.H. Robinson, the broker, had arranged the shipment.
Montgomery sued the driver, the carrier and the broker. His claim against C.H. Robinson was negligent hiring: that the broker knew, or should have known, that Caribe Transport was an unsafe choice. According to the complaint, the carrier held a “conditional” safety rating from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration at the time, with deficiencies in driver qualification and hours of service.
C.H. Robinson argued that a 1994 federal law, the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA), blocked the claim. That law preempts state laws “related to a price, route, or service” of a motor carrier or broker. The trial court and the Seventh Circuit agreed with the broker. The Sixth and Ninth Circuits had reached the opposite answer in earlier cases, so the outcome depended on where the crash happened.
What the Supreme Court decided
The Court reversed, 9 to 0, in an opinion by Justice Barrett. The FAAAA has a safety exception: it does not restrict “the safety regulatory authority of a State with respect to motor vehicles.” A claim that a broker carelessly hired an unsafe trucking company concerns the trucks on the road, the Court said, so it falls inside that exception. The holding in one line: a claim that one company negligently hired another to transport goods is not preempted by the FAAAA.
Three details matter for brokers reading the decision:
- Nobody has been found liable yet. The ruling sends the case back to the lower courts. Montgomery still has to prove that C.H. Robinson failed to use reasonable care and that the failure caused his injuries.
- It covers interstate loads. A separate part of the statute deals with brokers arranging intrastate moves and has no safety exception. Justice Kavanaugh noted that all sides agreed state tort suits over intrastate arrangements remain barred.
- Careful brokers have a defense. In a concurrence joined by Justice Alito, Justice Kavanaugh wrote that the decision “should not be read to mean that brokers will routinely be subject to state tort liability in the wake of truck accidents.” Brokers who act reasonably and hire reputable carriers should be able to defend themselves.
The freight broker exposure, summarized
Before May, a broker in Illinois, Indiana or Wisconsin could often get a negligent hiring claim dismissed at the start, on preemption alone. That exit is closed. Here is what the exposure looks like now.
- Carrier selection is a legal duty. Negligent hiring means failing to use reasonable care when choosing a contractor for work that can hurt people. Every tender is a hiring decision that a jury can review later.
- The claims are the large ones. These suits follow serious crashes, and plaintiffs look past the carrier when the carrier's insurance runs out. Federal rules set the minimum auto liability for most general freight carriers at $750,000. A catastrophic injury can exceed that many times over.
- Federal law does not make brokers carry liability insurance. Justice Kavanaugh pointed out that the statute sets a minimum level of insurance coverage for trucking companies and none for brokers. A broker's $75,000 bond covers unpaid freight bills, not bodily injury.
- Winning still costs money. The concurrence says it plainly: “the costs to brokers of litigation and insurance may be significant even when brokers prevail in lawsuits.”
- Your records are your defense. The case against C.H. Robinson rests on what the public safety data showed on the day of the tender. The question in every future case will be the same: what did the broker check, and what did it do about what it found?
Montgomery's own lawyer described the standard at oral argument, in a line the concurrence quotes: “the broker is not going to have a problem if it's asking the hard questions of the carrier.” The work for brokers is to ask those questions on every load and keep the answers.
How CargoLabs helps freight brokers
Insurance does not replace carrier vetting. What it does is put more money behind the truck, and a per-load certificate puts proof of your check in the file. Both are available in minutes on CargoLabs, at any hour.
The carrier's liability limit is too thin for the load
The fix: Per-trip excess auto liability
Nobody can show what was verified on the day of the load
The fix: Broker tools on CargoLabs
The cargo is worth more than the carrier's cargo limit
The fix: Excess single trip cargo insurance
The carrier you vetted is not the carrier that shows up
One more for brokers who work with owner-operators: the CargoLabs occupational accident bundle includes contingent liability that names the shipper and the broker on a load as additional insureds for that load.
A carrier selection checklist after Montgomery
Five habits that turn “asking the hard questions” into a record:
- Check the carrier's FMCSA safety rating and authority status before every tender, not only at onboarding.
- Write down what you do when a rating is conditional or the data shows a problem. Then follow it.
- Confirm active insurance for the specific load, and match the limits to the freight and the lane.
- Save the certificate, the safety snapshot and the date with the load file.
- Ask your own agent how your contingent auto liability policy responds to a negligent hiring claim.
When a load calls for more than the carrier's standard limits, you can compare every coverage side by side or start a free quote and have the certificate in your inbox before the truck is dispatched.